A HISTORY OF THE IDEA OF SUBLUXATION: A REVIEW OF THE MEDICAL LITERATURE TO THE 20TH CENTURY

Main Article Content

Phillip Ebrall
Gary Bovine

Keywords

History of Medicine, Spine, Subluxation

Abstract

Introduction: To present an historical narrative reporting the different interpretations over time of the concept of subluxation, an idea extant in chiropractic from the time of its founding by DD Palmer in 1895 and which forms chiropractic’s professional identity globally.


Methods: Our starting point was the idea that ‘small, repairable lesions in the spine that affect wellbeing’ first appeared in the medical writings of the Egyptians, while it also emerged in Greek medical writings and then in Latin, where the idea was semantically codified as ‘subluxation.’ We each followed the standard practices of historians to identify textbooks and journal papers to the end of the 19th Century that we felt contributed to the narrative. Through a process of heuristics we extracted relevant phrases and here cite them verbatim and with comment. The reader will note a variety of spellings and expressions uncommon today as we have reproduced the exact spelling and phrases as variously published.


Results: This report shows that the idea of subluxation has been well documented within ancient writings, absent for a time and then resurfacing in medical writings from the 14th Century. We present summary notes of its many clinical descriptions up to the time that medicine narrowed its definition, about the end of the 19th Century to that of ‘spinal irritation,’ which lost its meaning by the 20th Century. The idea was revived as ‘subluxation’ by DD Palmer.


Conclusion: The idea of subluxation is as old as the medical literature and we establish a strong presence in the medical literature for the idea expressed in terms of neurological change associated with functional derangement. Palmer maintained medicine’s metaphysical understanding of subluxation primarily as the effects from subluxed vertebrae and this paper traces both the physical and metaphysical meanings attributed by practitioners who were prominent in their time as evidenced by their writings.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.
Abstract 35 | IDEA OF SUBLUXATION Downloads 35

References

1. Ebrall P. The conventional identity of chiropractic and its negative skew. J Contemp Chiropr 2020;3(1):111-126. URL https://journal.parker.edu/index.php/jcc/article/view/133
2. Noveck IA, Reboul A. Experimental pragmatics: a Gricean turn in the study of language. Trends Cog Sci 2006;12(11):425-30. DOI 0.1016/j.tics.2008.07.009
3. Ebrall P. DD Palmer and the Egyptian connection: A short report. Asia-Pac Chiropr J 2020;1:1-8. URL https://www.apcj.net/ebrall-egyptian-palmer-and-subluxation/
4. Bovine G. From the Greek exarthrema, pararthrema, to the Latin luxatio, subluxatio: Origins and early definitions of the word ‘subluxation.’ Chiropr Hist 2018;38(1):12-19
5. Bovine G. Hippocrates. manual manipulation of the spine revisited: καταναγκάξειν -reduce it forcibly, εμβολή-throw, thrust, ram, push, reduction. Chiropr Hist 2019;39(2):11-18
6. Bovine G. The Nicetas Code Manuscript: Hippocratic 10th century writings in the Biblioteca Medicea Laurenziana. Chiropr Hist 2018;38(2):14-18
7. Tagault J. Institute of Surgery of Giouanni Tagaultio, Medical illustrations in 5 volumes. Venice: Giorgo Angelieri. 1570. Also imprinted 1585
8. McDowall D. Before Chiropractors and Osteopaths did anything, An English physician did it all -A comparative review of Edward Harrison’s tome. Chiropr Hist 2007;27(2):79-85
9. Weiner MF, Silver JR. Edward Harrison and the treatment of spinal deformities in the nineteenth century. J R Coll Physicians Edinb 2008;38(3):265-271. PMID: 19227603
10. Inglis, B.D., (Chairman). (1979). Chiropractic in New Zealand. Report of the Commission of Inquiry presented to the House of Representatives by Command of His Excellency the Governor-General. Wellington: Hasselberg, Government Printer
11. Bebinger M. As the opium trade boomed In The 1800s, Boston doctors raised addiction concerns. Boston: Radio WBUR. Aug 1 2017. URL https://www.wbur.org/commonhealth/2017/08/01/opium-history-addiction
12. McDowall D, Chaseling M, Emmanuel E, et al. Daniel David Palmer, the Father of Chiropractic: his heritage revisited. A story of enlightenment, spiritualism and innovation. Chiropr Hist 2019;31(1):25-40
13. Serny JB. A treatise of local inflammation more particularly applied to diseases of the eye. London: Self published. 1809
14. Dr James Fever Powder. Letters to the admiralty/out-letters/records of Medical and Prisoner of War Departments Office of the Commissioners of Sick and Wounded Seamen (Sick and Hurt Board) and successors/Admiralty records/Public Record Office/1673-1957 (microform). Accessed via Trove: URL https://nla.gov.au/nla.obj-732118366/view
15. Entry, October 2010: Jennifer Welsh, Dr. James’s Fever Powder, circa 1746. Dr. James’s fever powder, patented by English physician Robert James, claimed to cure fevers and various other maladies, from gout and scurvy to distemper in cattle. Though its efficacy was often questioned, the powder had “a long tradition of usage,” from its introduction in 1746 well into the 20th century, says John Crellin, a professor of medical humanities at Memorial University of Newfoundland. It was even prescribed to King George III when he was suffering from cataracts, rheumatism and dementia at the end of his life. The Scientist. URL https://www.the-scientist.com/uncategorized/dr-james-fever-powder-circa-1746-43055
16. Homewood AE. The neurodynamics of the vertebral subluxation. 3e. St Petersburg FL. Valkyrie Press. 1977
17. Gillies H. The theory and practice of counter-irritation. London: Macmillan. 1895
18. Gillies H. The theory and practice of counter-irritation [Review]. American J Med Sci 1986:04:453-454. URL https://doi.org/10.1097/00000441-189604000-00007
19. Riadore JE. A treatise on irritation of spinal nerves as the source of nervousness, indigestion, functional and organical derangements of the principal organs of the body. London: J Churchill Princes Street Soho. 1842
20. Pallen M. Spinal irritation. In: Early Doctor of Medicine and Doctor of Physic Dissertations with Corrected Tables of Contents. University of Maryland. 1835
21. Robb-Smith AHT. A history of the College’s nomenclature of diseases: its preparation. J Roy Coll Phycns Lond 1969;3(4):341-58. URL https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5367131/pdf/jrcollphyslond90265-0037.pdf
22. Editors. The nomenclature of diseases from the standpoint of public medicine. Br Med J 1896;22:469. URL https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2510340/pdf/brmedj08809-0037a.pdf.
23. Stocks P. Nomenclature of disease. Br Med J 1949;6:321. URL https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2050594/pdf/brmedj03636-0027a.pdf
24. Weissman G. “Spinal irritation” and fibromyalgia: a surgeon general and the three graces. FASEB J (Editorial) 2008;:327-31. Accessed through ResearchGate. URL https://www.researchgate.net/publication/5613010_Spinal_Irritation_and_Fibromyalgia_A_Surgeon_General_and_the_Three_Graces
25. McDowall DA. Daniel David Palmer's heritage and his legacy of tone to chiropractic [Thesis]. Southern Cross University. 2021. Appendix D, pp 277-88. URL https://doi.org/10.25918/thesis.121
26. Faulkner TJ. The chiropractor’s protégé. Assoc Hist Chiropr: Rock Island, IL 2017:72
27. Palmer DD. Text book of the science, art and philosophy of chiropractic for students and practitioners Portland: Portland Printing House Company. 1910:713.