MERGING HEALTH PROFESSIONS: EVIDENCE FOR A POSSIBLE CHIROPRACTIC-MEDICAL MERGER

Main Article Content

Peter Rome

Keywords

Osteopathy, Medicine, History of Medicine

Abstract

Background: Research has been conducted to examine the circumstances and the accuracy of reports relating to an offer from medicine to integrate chiropractic in California around 1960. The offer sought to exchange chiropractors’ registration to that of medical doctors.


Objective: The primary objective of this study is to identify various sources regarding this purported move by organised medicine in the United States.  A document or formal published reference was its ultimate aim.


Method: Following mention in source chiropractic texts, I decided to explore as many sources as possible. Contract was made with institutions and individuals as well as a comprehensive search of medical and chiropractic indexes as well as via a general search engine.


Results: In 1961 in California, a similar offer was made to osteopaths who had adopted a number of medical practices such as surgery, gynecology and drug prescription, in order to merge with medicine. For chiropractors, only circumstantial evidence could be found related to such discussions. However, contact between the 2 professions on such a proposal appears to have been floated on 4 occasions. In addition, verbal evidence from chiropractic graduates from the 1950-60’s do recall such discussions.


Conclusion.: No formal confirmatory evidence or such a proposal could be located.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.
Abstract 40 | MERGING PROFESSIONS Downloads 20

References

1. Goldstein MS.(1) Alternative health care - medicine, miracle or mirage. Philadelphia: Temple University Press, 1999
2. Reforming America’s healthcare system through choice and competition. U.S. Dept Health & Human Services, U.S. Dept of the Treasury, U.S. Dept Labor. https://www.hhs.gov/sites/default/files/Reforming-Americas-Healthcare-System-Through-Choice-and-Competition.pdf?utm_source=newsletter&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=newsletter_axiosvitals&stream=top. (Accessed 13 Oct 2019)
3. Smith JC. Reforming Georgia’s Workers’ Compensation through choice, competition and chiropractic care. https://documentcloud.adobe.com/link/track?uri=urn%3Aaaid%3Ascds%3AUS%3A70671a8f-9bfc-446d-ab12-9f9441d7aa3d. (Accessed 13 Oct 2019)
4. Smith JC. Reforming American healthcare. https://chiropractorsforfairjournalism.com/Reforming_Healthcare.html (Accessed 13 Oct 2019)
5. Green BN, Johnson CD. Interprofessional collaboration in research, education, and clinical practice: working together for a better future. J Chiropr Educ 2015;29(1):1-10
6. Dafny LS, Lee TH. Health care needs real competition. Harvard Business Review. 2016. https://hbr.org/2016/12/health-care-needs-real-competition (Extracted 13.10.2019.)
7. Gaynor M, Mostashari F, Ginsburg P. Health care’s crushing lack of competition. Forbes. June 28, 2017. https://www.forbes.com/sites/realspin/2017/06/28/health-cares-crushing-lack-of-competition/#7a585d5d14ff
8. Inglis B. Fringe Medicine. London: Faber & Faber; 1964;114
9. Reinsch S, Seffinger M, Tobis J. The merger: M.Ds and D.Os in California. Los Angeles: Xlibris, Self-Publishing Co. 2009
10. Wilk CA. Chiropractic speaks out. A reply to medical propaganda, bigotry and ignorance. Park Ridge, Ill: Wilk Publishing Co; 1973:97
11. Wardwell WI. Chiropractic: history and evolution of a new profession. St Louis: Mosby Year Book;1992:139-141
12. Logan J, Green DG, Woodfield A. Healthy competition. Auckland. The Centre for Independent Studies. 1989
13. Wilk CA. Medicine, monopolies and malice. Garden City Park, New York. Avery Publishing Group. 1996;159
14. Smith JC. The medical war against chiropractors. The untold story from persecution to vindication. Self-Published. 2011
15. Burkhart LA. Wilk v. AMA 25 years later: why it still isn’t over. ACA News. March 2012
16. Rubinstein HM. ,Wilk v. AMA: The lingering effects of an inadequate injunction to remedy malignant anti-trust violations against the chiropractic profession - a search for the cure to federal and state executive, legislative, and judiciary inaction to continued discrimination of chiropractic as related especially to insurance, 11 U. Miami Bus. L. Rev. 131 (2003) (Available at: http://repository.law.miami.edu/umblr/vol11/iss1/6)
17. Beychok T. Wilk v. AMA: almost thirty years later Chiropr Econ. 2015. https://www.chiroeco.com/wilk-v-ama-almost-thirty-years-later/Accessed Oct 13, 2019
18. Baer H. Biomedicine and alternative healing systems in America. University of Wisconsin. 2001
19. Wolinsky H, Brune T M. Medical monopoly waging war on alternative medicine. In: The serpent on the staff. The unhealthy politics of the American Medical Association. New York: G.P. Putnam's Sons, 1994:121-122
20. Boudreau LA, Busse JW, McBride G. Chiropractic services in the Canadian Armed Forces: a pilot project. Mil Med. 2006;171(6):572-576
21. Anon. Veteran's Affairs Canada. 2013. www.chiropracticcanada.ca/en-us/.../VeteransAffairs Canada
22. Paskowski I, Schneider M, Stevans J, Ventura JM, Justice BD. A hospital-based standardised spine care pathway: report of a multidisciplinary, evidence-based process. J Manipulative Physiol Ther 2011;34(2):98-106
23. Staff. Brigham and Women's Hospital, June 30th 2012. http://www.brighamandwomens.org/departments_and_services/medicine/services/oshercenter/aboutus_staff.aspx?sub=0
24. Anon. Department of Defense Liaison with New Chiropractic Benefits Committee Addresses Chiropractic Coalition Legislative Day Gathering. Circa 2005. http://www.chiropractic.org/index.php?p=news/deptofdefense
25. Anon. Chiropractic care residency pilot initiative. New chiropractic care program. Dept of Veterans Affairs. July 23rd. 2013. http://www.va.gov/oaa/archive/20130723_ChiropracticResidency_RFP.PDF
26. Rome PL. Chiropractic hospital appointments in Australia – an international comparison. Chiropr J Aust 2016;44(2):142-163
27. Keating J. The Search for a Science of Straight Chiropractic: Herbert Marshall Himes, D.C., Ph.C., F.I.C.C. Dynamic Chiropractic – December 14, 2000;18(26):http://www.dynamicchiropractic.com/mpacms/dc/article.php?id=32046
28. Wilk CA. Chiropractic speaks out. A reply to medical propaganda, bigotry and ignorance. Park Ridge, Ill: Wilk Publishing Co; 1973:97
29. Keating JC, Phillips RB. A history of Los Angeles Chiropractic College. Whittier: Southern California University of Health Sciences; 2001
30. Prescott D. Lessons from the California practice rights litigation, Part 6: Who's in charge? elective education and training. www.prescott-law.com/.../Fourth%20Series%20-%20Part%206%20. http://www.chiropracticuniverse.com/mobile/ITEM-Lessons-from-the-California-practice-rights-litigation-Part-13-Certifying-the-practice-of-homeopathy-3829.html
31. McCready LA, Harris B. From quackery to quality assurance: The first twelve decades of the Medical Board of California. Sacramento, Ca., 1995;109pps
32. Rubinstein HM. Wilk v. AMA: The lingering effects of an inadequate injunction to remedy malignant anti-trust violations against the chiropractic profession - a search for the cure to federal and state executive, legislative, and judiciary inaction to continued discrimination of chiropractic as related especially to insurance. University of Miami Business Law Review. 2003. http://repository.law.miami.edu/umblr/vol11/iss1/6/
33. Hays J. The untold story behind the AMA's plot to destroy chiropractic https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vXP-vzBdqQA&feature=youtu.be
34. Andrews GP. Press release. Aug 28, 1987. http://www.mccoypress.net/docs/subscriber_extras/wilk_press_release.pdf
35. Baer HA. Divergence and convergence in two systems of manual medicine: osteopathy and chiropractic in the United States. Med Anthrop Quarterly, New Series. 1987;1(2):176-193
36. Ex-chiropractors enter training as MD assistants. American Medical News. November 15, 1971:8-9. (Cited by Wilk CA (12) p. 97.)
37. Chiropractors as physicians' assistants. Medical Economic News, April 12, 1971:48. (Cited by Wilk CA. (12) p.97.)
38. Wardwell WI. Differential evolution of osteopathic and chiropractic professions in the United States. Perspectives Biol Med. 1994;37(4):595-608.
39. Gibbons RW. Chiropractors as interns, residents and staff: the hospital experience, 1910-1960. Chiropr Hist 1983;3(1):51-57
40. Gibbons RW. Physician-chiropractors: medical presence in the evolution of chiropractic. Bull Hist Med 1981;55:233-245
41. W.H.O. Guidelines on basic training and safety in chiropractic. 2005. Geneva. World Health Organisation 2005:27 http://www.who.int/medicines/areas/traditional/Chiro-Guidelines.pdf
42. Chapman Smith D. 2007 21(2). W.H.O. conversion course for MDs & physiotherapists to become chiropractors. The Chapman-Smith Report 2007;2:3
43. Zhang X. Coordinator Traditional Medicines. WHO guidelines on basic training and safety in chiropractic. Geneva. World Health Organisation. 2005:11. http://apps.who.int/medicinedocs/en/d/Js14076e/ W.H.O. Guidelines on basic training and safety in chiropractic.
44. Medical correspondent. Doctors to study art of massage. Sydney Morning Herald, 1972; July 15
45. Spinal manipulation. https://www.learnspinalmanipulation.com/ Extracted Oct 13, 2019
46. Coughlin P. Bezilla T. AMSA EDAM Initiative: a national curriculum for medical students. Chiropractic and osteopathy. CAM Education Committee, ACAM – American College for the Advancement of Medicine.2002. Cited now on: https://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/the-american-medical-student-association-a-corrosive-force/
47. Johnson PJ, Ward A, Knutson L, Sendeelbach S.. Personal use of complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) by US healthcare workers. Health Serv Res online, 2011
48. Dawson M. Doctors, nurses often use holistic medicine for themselves. Center for Aging Health. http://www.cfah.org/hbns/2011/doctors-nurses-often-use-holistic-medicine-for-themselves
49. Eastwood HL. Complementary therapies: the appeal to general practitioners. Med J Aust. 2000;173:95-98
50. Wardwell WI. A marginal professional role: the chiropractor. Social Forces 1952;30:339-348
51. Trevor W. In the public interest. Los Angeles. Scriptures Unlimited..1972.
52. Berliner HS, Salmon JW. The holistic alternative to scientific medicine: history and analysis. Int J Health Serv 1980;10(1):133-147
53. Bracha Y, Svendsen K, Culliton P. Patient visits to a hospital-based alternative medicine clinic from 1997-2002: experience from an integrated healthcare system. Explor. 2005;1(1):13-20
54. Branson, RA. Hospital-based chiropractic integration within a large private hospital system in Minnesota: a 10-year example. J Manipulative Physiol Ther. 2009;32(9):740-748
55. Dunn AS, Green BN, Gilford S. An analysis of the integration of chiropractic services within the United States military and veterans' health care systems. J Manipulative Physiol Ther 2009;32(9):749-757
56. Garner MJ, Birmingham M, Aker P, et al. Developing integrative primary healthcare delivery: adding a chiropractor to the team. Explore (NY) Jan-Feb 2008;4(1):18-24
57. Green BN, Johnson CD, Daniels CJ, Napuli JG, Gliedt JA, Paris DJ. Integration of chiropractic services in military and vetwean health care facilities: a systematic review of the literature. J Evid Based Complimentary Altern Med 2016;21(2):115-130
58. Green BN, Johnson CD, Lisi AJ, Tucker J. Chiropractic practice in military and veterans health care: The state of the literature. J Canad Chiropr Assn 2009;53(3):194-204
59. Horwitz AD, Hosek R, Boyle J, Ciancuilli A, Glass J, Codario R. A new gatekeeper for back pain. Am J Manag Care 1998;4(4):576-579
60. Pfefer M, Strunk R, Hawk C, Ramcharan M, Pa Xiong E, Hill D, Davis L, et al. Integration of Chiropractic Services into a Multidisciplinary Safety-Net Clinic. Topics in Integrative Health Care 2010, Vol. 1(1) ID: 1.1005. http://www.tihcij.com/Articles/Integration-of-Chiropractic-Services-into-a-Multidisciplinary-Safety-Net-Clinic.aspx?id=0000204
61. Sarnat RL, Winterstein J, Cambron JA. Clinical utilization and cost outcomes from an integrative medicine independent physician association: an additional 3-year update. J Manipulative Physiol Ther 2007;30(4):263-269
62. Press Release. Dr. Anthony Hamm Brings History of Interprofessional Cooperation and Payment Policy Expertise. www.acatoday.org/press_css.cfm?CID=5431‎. March 7, 2014
63. Press Release.. ACA Delegate Dr. Anthony Hamm Is First DC Elected Co-Chair of AMA HCPAC Review Board. www.acatoday.org/press_css.cfm?CID=4430. May 18, 2011
64. Editorial. Soviet medical school to offer chiropractic degree. www.dynamicchiropractic.com/mpacms/dc/article.php?id=44513
65. Shpilko I. Russian-American health care: Bridging the communication gap between physicians and patients. Patient Educ Counselling 2006;64:331-341
66. Pikalov A. Manipulative therapy in Russia. Part 1. Dynamic Chiropr, 1994:12(2). http://www.dynamicchiropractic.com/mpacms/dc/article.php?id=41027
67. Lewit K, Ellis RM. The place of manipulative therapy and its future. In: Manipulative Therapy. Chapter 10. 2010;377-380. https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/medicine-and-dentistry/manual-medicine
68. Francis R. Spinal manipulation under general anaesthesia: a chiropractic approach in a hospital setting. ACA J Chiropr 1989 Dec;12:39-41
69. International MUA Academy of Physicians. Manipulation under anaesthesia didactic and clinical proctoring protocol for MUA certification courses. http://www.muaphysicians.com/protocols.html
70. Lewit K. Manipulative therapy in rehabilitation of the locomotor system. 3rd ed. Oxford, Butterworth Heinemann. 1999
71. Biedermann H, Manual therapy in children. Edinburgh, Churchill Livingstone. 2004
72. Maigne R. Orthopaedic medicine: A new approach to vertebral manipulations. 1972:164
73. Rome PL. Commentary: Medical evidence recognising the vertebral subluxation complex. Chiropr J Aust 2016;44(4):304-307
74. Rome PL. Commentary: A basis for the theory of a central chiropractic principle - the vertebral subluxation. Chiropr J Aust 2012;43(1):2-10
75. Sato A, Sato Y, Schmidt RF. Somatosensory modulation of the digestive system. In: The impact of somatosensory input on autonomic functions. Reviews of Physiology Biochemistry and Pharmacology. Blaustein MP et al Eds. Springer-Verlag, Berlin. 1997;v130
76. Sato A. Somatovisceral reflexes. J Manipulative Physiol Ther 1995;18(9):597-602
77. Sato A, The reflex effects of spinal somatic nerve stimulation on visceral function. J Manipulative Physiol Ther 1992;15(1):57-61
78. Cramer G D, Darby SA. Basic and clinical anatomy of the spine, spinal cord, and ANS. St Louis, Publisher: Mosby-Yearbook: 1995
79. Bakkum BW, Henderson CNR, Hong SP, Cramer GD. Preliminary morphological evidence that vertebral hypermobility induces synaptic plasticity in the spinal cord. J Manipulative Physiol Ther 2007;30(5):336-342
80. Jänig W. The integrative action of the autonomic nervous system. Neurobiology of homeostasis. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press;2006
81. King HH, Jänig W, Patterson MM. The science and clinical application of manual therapy. Edinburgh. Churchill Livingstone/Elsevier. 2011
82. Pickar JG, McLain RF. Responses of mechanosensitive afferents to manipulation of the lumbar facet in the cat. Spine 1995;20(22):2379-2385
83. Korr IM (ed). The Neurobiological Mechanisms in Manipulative Therapy. New York, Plenum Press, 1978
84. Jinkins JR. The pathoanatomic basis of somatic, autonomic and neurogenic syndromes originating in the lumbosacral spine. In: Giles LGF, Singer KP, Clinical anatomy and management of low back pain. Vol 1. Jordan Hill: Butterworth Heinemann; 1997. p. 255-272
85. Muller R, Giles L G.F. Long-term follow-up of a randomised clinical trial assessing the efficacy of medication, acupuncture, and spinal manipulation for chronic mechanical spinal pain syndromes. J Manipulative Physiol Ther. 2005;28(1):3-11
86. Bolton PS, Kerman IA, Woodring SF, Yates BJ. Influences of neck afferents on sympathetic and respiratory nerve activity. Brain Res Bull 1998;47:413-419
87. Green BN, Johnson CD. International collaboration in research, education, and clinical practice: working together for a better future. Chiropr Educ 2015;29(1):1-10
88. Riva JJ, Muller GD, Hornich AA, et al. Chiropractors and collaborative care: an overview illustrated with a case report. J Canad Chiropr Assoc 2010;54(3):147-154
89. Pickar JG. Neurophysiological effects of spinal manipulation. Spine J 2002;2(5):357-371
90. Haavik-Taylor H, Murphy B. Cervical spine manipulation alters sensorimotor integration: A somatosensory evoked potential study. Clin Neurophysiol 2007;118(2):391-402
91. Rome PL. Neurovertebral influence upon the autonomic nervous system: some of the somato-autonomic evidence to date. Part I. [Table 5. Animal research on visceral dysfunction, neural disturbance and the vertebral subluxation.] Chiropr J Aust 2009;39(1)2-17
92. Cleveland CS. Researching the subluxation of the domestic rabbit: a pilot research program conducted at the Cleveland Chiropractic College. Pub Cleveland Chiropractic College, Kansas City, Missouri, 24pps. (See also Sci Review Chiropr Aug 1965;(4):5-28
93. Agocs S. Cleveland’s rabbits: the use of animals to study vertebral subluxation. Chiropr Hist 2016;36(1))63-69
94. Burns L, Chandler LC, Rice RW. Pathogenesis of visceral disease following vertebral lesions. .Am Osteop Assoc Chicago 1948. (Note Dr Burns has also published at length on her extensive research, particularly in the J Am Osteop Assoc and the AT Still Research Institute Bull, the most recent is circa 1953.)
95. Rome PL, McKibbin MR. A review of chiropractic veterinary science – an emerging profession with somatic and somatovisceral anecdotal histories. Chiropr J Aust 2011;41(4):127-139
96. Rome PL. Animal chiropractic neutralises the claim of placebo effect of spinal manipulation: historical perspective. Chiropr J Aust 2012;42(1):15-20
97. Kamen D, The well-adjusted dog. Brookline MA. Brookline Books, 1996
98. Kamen D. The well-adjusted cat. Cambridge MA. Brookline Books. 1997
99. Kamen D. The well-adjusted horse. BrooklineMA. Brookline Books. 1998
100. Browning D. Animal chiropractic: the new family practice. ICA Rev 2007;63(3):29-35
101. Rosner A. Getting down to brass tacks: the neurophysiology of spinal manipulation. Dynamic Chiropr 2015;33(17) https://www.dynamicchiropractic.com/mpacms/dc/article.php?id=57469
102. Lindahl O, Hamberg J. Angina pectoris symptoms caused by thoracic spine disorders. Neuro-anatomical considerations. Acta Med Scand Suppl 1981;644:81-83
103. Sjaastad O, Saunte C, Hovdahl H, Breivik H, Grønbaek E. Cervicogenic" headache. An hypothesis. Cephalalgia 1983 Dec;3(4):249-256
104. Krag E. Other causes of dyspepsia - especially abdominal pain of spinal origin. Scand J Gastroenterol Suppl 1982;79:32-37
105. Bogduk N. Cervicogenic headache: Anatomic basis and pathophysiological mechanisms. Curr Pain Headache Rep 2001;5(4):382-386
106. Bogduk N, Lambert G, Duckworth JW. The anatomy and physiology of the vertebral nerve in relation to cervical migraine. Cephalgia 1981;1:11-24
107. Vaňásková E, Hep A, Lewit K, et al. Cervical dysfunction with disturbed oesophageal motility – scintigraphic assessment. J Orthop Med 2001;23(1):9-11.
108. Rome PL Medical management of pediatric and non-musculoskeletal conditions by spinal manipulation. Chiropr J Aust 2013;43(4):131-136
109. Rome P, Waterhouse J, Maginness G, Ebrall P. Medical management of infantile colic and other conditions with spinal manipulation: a narrative review of European medical literature. J Contemp Chiropr 2019;2:60-75
110. Lauretti WJ. What are the Risks of Chiropractic Neck Adjustments? 2003. http://www.chiro.org/LINKS/FULL/What_are_the_Risk_of_Chiropractic.shtml
111. Neck adjustment: benefits and safety. Chiropractic College of British Columbia. October, 2009. www.bcchiro.com/.../2009-10-neck_adjustment_benefits_and_safety.pdf
112. Rosner A. chiropractic care and risk of stroke: the shoe moves to the other foot. 2015;33(15). http://www.dynamicchiropractic.com/mpacms/dc/article.php?id=57444
113. Cassidy JD, Boyle E, Côté P, et al. Risk of vertebrobasilar stroke and chiropractic care: Results of a population-based case-control and case crossover study. Spine 2008;33(4 Suppl):S176-183
114. Cassidy JD, Boyle E, Côté P, Hogg-Johnson S, Bondy SJ, Haldeman S. Risk of carotid stroke after chiropractic care: a population-based case-crossover study. J Stroke Cardiovasc Dis, 2016
115. Whedon JM, Mackenzie TA, Phillips RB, Lurie JD. Risk of traumatic injury associated with chiropractic spinal manipulation in Medicare Part B beneficiaries aged 66-99. Spine 2015;40(4):264-270
116. Church EW, Sieg EP, Zalatimo O, et al. Systematic review and meta-analysis of chiropractic care and cervical artery dissection: no evidence of causation. Cureus 8(2): e498. DOI 10.7759/cureus.498
117. Todd AJ, Carroll MT, Robinson A, Mitchell EKL. Adverse events due to chiropractic and other manual therapies for infants and children: A review of the literature. J Manipulative Physiol Ther 2015;38(9):699-712. DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jmpt.2014.09.008
118. Getzendanner S. Getzendanner Decision in the United States District Court for the Northern District of Illinois Eastern Division. 1987. No. 76 C 3777
119. Getzendanner S. Permanent injunction order against AMA. J Am Med Assoc 1988;259:81–82
120. Wilk et al., v. American Medical Assn. et al., 671 F. Supp. 1465 (1987), aff’d, 895 F. 2nd 352 (7th Cir. 1990), cert. denied, 498 U.S. 982, 111 S. Crt. 513 (1990)
121. Willis E. Medical dominance. St Leonards. Allen and Unwin. 1989
122. Jonas W. Facts on Chiropractic. World Federation of Chiropractic, 2000. The Chiropractic Profession, NCMIC Group, 2000. http://www.wfc.org/website/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=122&Itemid=138&lang=en