INTRODUCTION
Interprofessional collaboration (IPC) is believed to improve health outcomes and patient satisfaction in medical care settings1 and to enhance athletic performance among professional and elite athletes.2 It has been repeatedly demonstrated that healthcare providers (HCPs) working together realize more positive outcomes).3,4 However, little research has examined recreational athletes and IPC, and a literature review found no studies on IPC in the chiropractic care of recreational runners (RRs). This is noteworthy given the increasing utilization of chiropractic care in the US5 and the finding that athletes’ utilization of chiropractic care is believed to exceed that of the general U.S. public.6
Research to address this gap is critical given the large number of RRs who may seek chiropractic care for injury prevention, treatment, and improved physical performance, making this study valuable as a base for more focused future exploration. Informing HCPs about the experiences, expectations, and perceived value of IPC for this group may spur further research to shape practice patterns that may facilitate positive outcomes and improve patient satisfaction among the large population of RRs.
Athletes and Chiropractic Care: Outcomes and Perceptions
The benefits of chiropractic care for elite athletes have been reported by numerous quantitative studies, including increased muscle strength, reduced reaction time, and improved lung function.7–10 Research has also shown improvements in functional athletic performance following spinal manipulative treatment (SMT), a mainstay of chiropractic services.2 Qualitative research has elicited elite athletes’ perceptions of the positive outcomes of chiropractic care. Researchers employed a semi-structured interview approach with Canadian national athletes, who reported that while they sought chiropractic care to reduce pain and discomfort, they also experienced improved athletic performance.11
Athletes and IPC in Chiropractic Care
Elite and professional athletes are familiar with IPC because multidisciplinary healthcare teams, including chiropractors, are routinely assembled to help them stay healthy, prevent injury, and maximize athletic performance.12 However, patient perspectives and descriptions of IPC teamwork have not been robustly studied in the context of sports and athletics.13–16
There have been a small number of published studies on IPC in chiropractic care and elite athletes. For example, in 2022 Hostrup and colleagues explored Danish athletes’ perceptions of IPC in chiropractic care. The authors concluded that professional and elite athletes expect and value IPC from their chiropractors, trainers, and physical therapists.17 Eindhoven’s team (2022) found that elite athletes desired greater communication and collaboration between their chiropractors and other members of their healthcare team.11
Interestingly, participant descriptions of the value of IPC in chiropractic care are not unanimously positive. When the chiropractors were off-site, respondents questioned the necessity of the modality, commenting that chiropractic care duplicated services that were already available.17 This was not the case when there was easy access to chiropractors and other HCPs.
Identified Research Gap
There is a clear knowledge gap regarding recreational athletes’ experiences and perceptions of IPC in chiropractic care, warranting further research. The research question of this study," How do recreational runners describe their experiences of interprofessional collaboration in chiropractic care?" seeks to expand the current body of information about how IPC is experienced by representatives of a large cohort group. Chiropractic was selected for study because utilization of chiropractic services continues to grow, and those involved in athletics are more likely to seek chiropractic care than those who are not.18 The results of this qualitative descriptive research may stimulate further investigation that may ultimately lead to more positive outcomes and greater satisfaction for RRs in chiropractic care.
METHODS
Design
This study used a qualitative descriptive design to explore how RRs in chiropractic care describe their experiences of IPC. Typical of studies employing this design, the data consisted of participants’ descriptions preserved in their own words with minimal researcher interpretation.19 This straightforward approach, which includes in vivo coding, emphasizes staying close to participants’ descriptions and minimizing researcher interpretation during data.20,21
The objectives of the study were to collect and organize descriptions of RR participants’ experiences of IPC in chiropractic care to contribute to the understanding of patient perspectives on IPC and to inform future research in this area. As is common in qualitative descriptive studies, a semi-structured interview (SSI) guide was developed and used to collect data. The SSI format is preferred because it facilitates in-depth discussion by allowing prompts and follow-ups, ensuring that the researcher understands the context of participants’ statements and comments,22 and affords the interviewer the flexibility to pose more questions to elicit additional data. The interview guide consisted of eight open-ended questions and related probes, which are listed in Table 1.
A purposive sampling method was used to recruit participants who met the study’s specific eligibility criteria: runners who had received chiropractic care concurrently with care from another healthcare professional, thereby enabling them to describe experiences related to IPC. This nonprobability sampling technique is recommended for identifying participants with specific characteristics, when perceptions and attitudes comprise the data,23 and when depth of information, rather than breadth, is sought.24 A purposive sampling method aligns with this study because it facilitates the recruitment of participants who meet the study’s specific criteria. Here, a specific subset of RRs was sought for participation in the study.
Contact was initiated with potential participants by posting a flyer on the websites of organized running groups in the targeted geographic area. The flyer outlined the study’s inclusion criteria: RRs were required to be English-speaking, 18 years of age or older, living in the Northeastern United States, and currently or previously in treatment simultaneously with a chiropractor and at least one other HCP. Interested participants contacted the researcher through email and Facebook Messenger. We sent e-mail invitations to participate to 12 individuals who had expressed interest in the study. The final sample consisted of 10 RRs, as 2 respondents had not received treatment from a chiropractor and from another HCP simultaneously, and therefore were unable to address the research question about IPC in chiropractic care.
This study was approved by Thomas Jefferson University’s Institutional Review Board (IRB Protocol No. IRISID-2025-0411) prior to participant recruitment and data collection. All participants provided informed consent before participation. Participants were informed that participation was voluntary and that they could withdraw from the study at any time without penalty. To protect confidentiality, identifying information was removed from interview transcripts, and participants were assigned identification numbers. Study data were stored securely and was accessible only to the research team.
Participants ranged in age from 42 to 67, and the group included five White women and five White men. Table 2 shows the participant demographics.
Data Collection
The interviews, lasting 25-40 minutes, were conducted synchronously by the researcher. They were audio- and video-recorded and transcribed via Zoom videoconferencing,25 following a clean approach in which non-substantive utterances were removed for readability. The transcripts were de-identified by the researcher.
Data Analysis
Cleaned transcripts were uploaded to the Dedoose qualitative data analysis software26 and coded using Saldaña’s19 The Coding Manual for Qualitative Researchers as a guide. In vivo quotes from participants were selected, descriptive codes assigned, and code definitions developed and documented. Interviews with the 10 participants generated sufficient information to address the research question via the range of experiences described.
The process of second coding by peers and faculty was then employed to ensure code integrity and to add, delete, or refine codes and related descriptions. The practice of second coding of transcripts, a form of investigator triangulation in which more than 1 researcher is recruited to cross-check and validate findings, enhances confirmability, a concept introduced by Gupta and Lincoln in 1989, that refers to the data truly representing the descriptions of the participants, which helps minimize researcher bias.27,28 All suggestions and disagreements were discussed by the researcher and the second coders until consensus was reached.
In the final step, Braun and Clarke’s thematic analysis approach was used to analyze the data, grouping related codes into categories by identifying patterns and then grouping these categories into themes.29 An inductive approach was used, in which themes emerged from participants’ descriptions without the influence of preconceived hypotheses.30 This method aligns with studies in which little previous investigation of the phenomenon has been conducted,30 as in the case of recreational athletes and IPC in chiropractic care.
While Braun and Clarke’s29 approach appears linear, the iterative process develops over time, entailing several readings of participant transcripts and the forming and reforming of codes and resulting themes to ensure that the results accurately reflect the participants’ descriptions.20,31,32
Trustworthiness
Guba and Lincoln’s criteria to ensure trustworthiness in qualitative research, commonly referred to as “the Four Dimension Criteria”, were employed.28 Table 3 illustrates the system components, definitions, and the application of the principles in this investigation.
RESULTS
The 5 themes identified in the data are presented in Table 4, along with corresponding definitions.
Theme 1: Expectations of IPC and the Patient Role
In their interviews, study participants reported not expecting to experience IPC among their HCPs. Participant 2 expressed it succinctly with this comment: “I really never expected them to talk. I mean, … if I’m being honest, that was not my expectation.” Participant 4 echoed the theme of non-expectation of IPC and added that IPC is rarely observed between separate practices: “That’s just the way it is, that there isn’t traditionally, in many areas, not that kind of communication, dialogue, interaction between very separate professional practices.”
The study participants offered reasons why they do not expect to experience IPC in chiropractic care. For example, Participant 5 commented that it is unreasonable for patients to expect IPC to be consistently implemented because of the business nature of healthcare. “You can’t expect one chiropractor to talk to all your other support staff, right? You have to be realistic about these things that…it’s a business, too, right?” Participant 6 suggested that IPC may not have occurred because trust was placed in her to manage the communication: “I’ve never known them to communicate with each other. I don’t know if it’s because they trust me to communicate back and forth.” Describing their limited expectations of IPC frequently led participants to comment on their roles as intermediaries between HCPs. Participant 2’s comment was typical. “So, it was all like any communication; it was just from me. They … had nothing to do with each other.” This sentiment was expressed by Participant 7 as well: “None other than me, I was the one that was the transcriber between the two.”
Because of their effectiveness and comfort in the go-between role, some participants expressed the opinion that IPC was unnecessary. Participant 4’s comment in relation to being the intermediary was “I was fine with it. I mean, … I’ve learned over the years, you have to be your own advocate a lot of times, you know”. Participant 7 described feeling that it was natural for her to assume the role, “I know how to walk the walk, and I know how to talk the talk… It was a no brainer for me to be that intermediary.” Not all participants reported the same level of confidence in serving as the messenger between HCPs. Participant 8 was not sure that communication would be accurate and complete without direct collaboration between providers, “I could see how it would be easier to…not be the person necessitating the communication because … if you didn’t have a certain level of education or understanding that you may not be translating it quite properly.”
It is noteworthy that the participants who reported not expecting or needing IPC between their chiropractor and other HCPs, such as Participant 6, identified that IPC is indicated for some chiropractic patients. “I don’t personally need the communication, but other people would probably benefit from more communication between the two.” Participant 7 agreed, “So, I think, if it was my husband or somebody else, it probably would have helped.”
Theme 2: Limited HCP Communication
Study participants identified other HCPs involved in their care as medical doctors, sports medicine doctors, podiatrists, acupuncturists, cardiologists, physical therapists, massage therapists, orthopedists and orthopedic surgeons. Participants reported that communication between the chiropractor and other involved HCPs often consisted solely of referrals, recommendations, and the sharing of medical records. Participant 4 described the limited communication between HCPs, “So, on the external partnership, there wasn’t a direct communication, unless you consider… a chart or…medical record transfer, but not like, call them up on the phone.” Participant 7, whose experience of IPC was limited to referrals, described frustration:
The chiropractor never talked to anybody but me. Other than refer me to the one non-surgical orthopod, right? And then the non-surgical orthopod referred me to the physical therapist, but then the non-surgical orthopod referred me to the surgical orthopod, but yes, other than just referring me, nobody really talked about my case.
Participants noted an added responsibility to fill in the gaps when HCP communication consisted only of sharing medical records. Participant 4 said the following:
You know, maybe you get a chart or something, but you don’t really see anything, because charts are charts, and so you’re giving all the backstory and context around what’s going on and what your end goals are, which don’t show up in a chart.
For many participants, the common practice of chiropractors and HCPs making referrals and recommendations and sharing medical records or reports without directly communicating or collaborating with other HCPs about their care, required them to assume the role of intermediaries.
Theme 3: Perceived Impact of IPC
The RRs who participated in the study and reported receiving IPC described perceived benefits of IPC in care and commended the collaborative practice. None described any perceived adverse impacts of IPC. Participant 1 perceived that IPC contributed to a faster recovery from injury. “The only thing was me getting fixed as expeditiously as possible. And that collaboration helped that happen. It was pretty smooth and efficient.” Participant 3 stated that IPC leads to a quicker return to running due to the synergistic effect of multiple HCPs working toward a positive result:
They knew more about me. The chiropractic care was able to, what’s the word I’m looking for? Sync with traditional care. Your traditional care could look at how they could use the chiropractor, along with any other rehab resources, to get you back to where you need to be. So, I think it got me back to running faster…The recovery time was less.
Participant 1 perceived that IPC reduced the need for additional evaluation and testing and expedited the rehabilitation process:
Well, it probably would have taken longer. Because I would have went in and I would have explained what I thought was going on. And then, the orthopedic surgeon would want to do some, not research, but, you know, some investigative work on my body, whether he wanted more tests done that were already done, or not done. You know, so he would have been…probably more cautious moving forward, which would include more tests and stuff, which would have just delayed the rehabilitation process.
Several participants described greater trust in the HCPs and greater confidence in the treatment plan when they experienced IPC. Participant 2 said it succinctly, “It just gives you more confidence in the decision.” Participant 3 elaborated on the feeling of confidence that comes from interdisciplinary agreement: “When you work with someone, and then you’re working with someone in traditional medicine, and they all work together, I think it helps give you confidence in going down a certain path.”
Participant 3 similarly perceived that collaboration among the chiropractor and other involved HCPs helped him successfully navigate the multi-professional treatment process and made him feel more comfortable with the care plan tailored to his individual needs:
I’m not a medical professional, but I’m going to assume it’s sort of more than one way to do something. And as a layperson, having someone else who navigates that road already for me just makes it easier. Much easier… more comfortable.
Some participant RRs who did not experience IPC believed that they might have had better outcomes, such as a more expedited recovery and a reduced risk of more severe injury, had IPC been implemented. Participant 2 commented:
I do believe that maybe if there was a way that everybody could have collaborated and gave them their two cents on what we should do with me, then maybe my problem could have been resolved sooner and without a significant injury happening. It would have been beneficial, yes.
Many participants described in general terms their perception that IPC would have resulted in a better experience for them. Participant 6 described IPC as being inherently beneficial. “There would be better care all the way around, right…if they communicated…so that would probably be a good thing, actually, if there was communication between the two of them.” Participant 1 shared a similar opinion. “Collaboration between medical professionals can only benefit the healing process.”
Theme 4: Perceived Facilitators of IPC
Study participants described perceived facilitators of IPC in chiropractic care, including chiropractors’ networks of HCPs and the co-location of the treatment team. Participants credit their chiropractors’ relationships with HCPs from other disciplines and their integration into the healthcare community as facilitating IPC. Participant 3 described it this way, “I don’t know if all chiropractors have the same network? But I think a good one does…utilizes and understands how to integrate themselves into the healthcare community to provide a more holistic healthcare service to you.”
In addition to chiropractic relationship-building and coordination with HCPs, study participants describe the co-location of the chiropractor with other HCPs as a facilitator of IPC. Participant 4 had this comment:
He does a pretty good job if it’s within his practice…there’s a benefit to having that all-in-one spot, too, right? Because it facilitates communication, it’s like I said, the dialogue, you can just knock on the door…could you take a look at this?
Theme 5: Perceived Barriers to IPC
Participants described barriers to IPC in chiropractic care. They included differing perspectives among HCPs, a lack of belief in chiropractic’s value and legitimacy, geographic barriers, and the constraints of the U.S. healthcare system.
This quote from Participant 2 illustrates that study participants perceive HCPs as reluctant to engage in IPC due to differing perspectives:
I think, like, they feel like, well. I do this… this is the way I do it, and they would say, well, this is the way I do it, and I don’t know that they would be so willing to sort of mesh. Just because, I don’t know, I feel like they each have their territory.
Participants said that IPC does not consistently occur because traditional HCPs do not respect chiropractors and may not view chiropractic care as a medical service beneficial to patients. Participant 8 commented, “I think there are still some that don’t necessarily view chiropractic the same way as they would view other doctors, maybe, like, other physicians or whatnot, so I think there’s definitely… some people still have preconceived notions.”
A third IPC barrier described by RR participants was a lack of co-location among the chiropractor and other HCPs. Participant 2 described it this way:
I mean, honestly, yeah, I guess sometimes I wish that they would talk to each other. They’re not in the same spaces, and it’s gonna take extra effort on somebody’s part to… or both of their parts, really, to send an email, or talk on the phone.
The current business focus of the U.S. health care system was described as a barrier to IPC because neither the fee-for-service nor the health maintenance organization models encourage or financially incentivize IPC. Health insurance also determines which providers a patient sees, and chiropractors and the specialists with whom they have developed relationships are not always in the same network. Participant 2 commented, “My insurance covered where I went. It didn’t cover the other place, so I wasn’t gonna pay out of pocket to go to a PT if I didn’t have to.” Similarly, Participant 4 made these comments:
If you spend time on that communication, you aren’t spending time with an additional patient, right? It’s not a billable charge, right? There’s not an insurance code for talk to or consult on another, right? As I said, there’s only so many hours in the day, and you have to keep the lights on.
DISCUSSION
Key Findings
This study explored RRs perspectives on IPC in chiropractic care. The five themes that emerged from the research were expectations of IPC and the patient role, limited HCP communication, perceived impact of IPC, perceived facilitators of IPC, and perceived barriers to IPC.
Regarding the first theme, expectations of IPC and the patient role, participants described their expectations of IPC and discussed how the lack of IPC affected their roles in the diagnostic and treatment process. Most participants did not expect IPC, and many did not experience it. The majority of those who described experiencing IPC had serious injuries that ultimately required surgical intervention. These findings may reflect a greater need for IPC as clinical complexity increases. Interestingly, that subset of participants also maintained the view that it is unreasonable to expect IPC in all chiropractic cases.
All 10 RRs interviewed spoke about the patient’s role as an intermediary among HCPs. Some were confident and comfortable in the role; others felt unsure they could disseminate accurate information or were frustrated at having to be the go-between. This aligns with existing literature. In their review, Sigmon et al.14 concluded that patients do not consistently understand or expect IPC. Chang et al. conducted a study on patients’ perspectives on healthcare coordination and found that many patients and family members were frustrated and burdened by the need to manage communication among HCPs when the professionals failed to do so.33
With respect to the second theme, limited HCP communication, participants frequently described communication between their chiropractor and other HCPs, if it occurred at all, as limited to referrals, recommendations, or sharing medical records, without discussion or coordinated plans of care. It may be posited that such limited coordination among disciplines does not constitute IPC, as defined by the World Health Organization34: professionals from different disciplines working together to provide quality care.
RRs’ descriptions of the benefits of IPC represent a third theme, the perceived impact of IPC. Those RRs who experienced IPC perceived that it expedited treatment and recovery, allowing them to return to running faster and, in some cases, delaying the need for surgery. They also described feeling more confident in the diagnosis and treatment plan when there was agreement among the HCPs involved in care. These descriptions are consistent with previous research in which patients report that IPC increases trust in HCPs13 and confidence in care plans.35 Some RRs who did not experience IPC in their care echoed similar comments, saying they wished their HCPs had collaborated on their care. All agreed that IPC does not emerge organically; it occurs with HCP intent. Participants who had experienced IPC during chiropractic care and those who had not both espoused the view that the lack of IPC is associated with a more difficult navigation through treatment with multiple providers and is perceived to produce less favorable outcomes. For example, participants associated the absence of IPC with delayed treatment and recovery from injury, missed opportunities for injury prevention, redundant testing, and inconsistent treatment recommendations.
Regarding the fourth theme, perceived facilitators of IPC, participants described the following: HCPs who were not competitive or territorial with one another, chiropractors who develop relationships with a network of providers from other disciplines, and co-location of HCPs. Co-location within the same practice has also been identified in existing literature as a facilitator of IPC.36 As noted in Hostrup’s study, co-location was an essential component of the valuation of chiropractic care and IPC.17 When HCPs are in the same practice, participants anticipate a higher likelihood of IPC.
The fifth theme, perceived barriers to IPC, included HCP territoriality and the increased effort required of HCPs to collaborate when not co-located in a single practice. Other deterrents to IPC, as described by participants, included distrust and devaluation of chiropractic care among other HCPs. Existing literature has explored barriers to IPC in chiropractic practice in primary healthcare centers and proposed that mistrust between HCPs and resistance to collaboration limit IPC.36,37 Theberge (2008) studied the integration of chiropractors into sports medicine healthcare teams. She noted that chiropractors’ meshing with other HCPs was sometimes compromised by chiropractors who act as primary care physicians. Chiropractors who assume that role had more difficulty finding their niche in the healthcare team.38
Finally, participants described the United States healthcare system as disincentivizing collaboration with other HCPs involved in their care. Regarding the current healthcare system, some RRs in the study noted that it is unrealistic to expect IPC in all cases due to the non-reimbursed time it requires. They elaborated that they believe there are no real financial incentives for providers to engage in IPC. Even when HCPs want to collaborate, systemic organizational barriers exist, such as fee-for-service reimbursement, which discourages teamwork, and the hierarchical structures of healthcare systems, which lead to fragmented care.39,40
The findings of this study show that the cohort of RRs appears to have distinct and important experiences and expectations regarding IPC compared with their better-studied professional-athlete counterparts. Professional and elite athletes expect IPC between their chiropractors and the other members of the healthcare team17 while many RRs do not describe similar expectations. In addition, elite and professional athletes specifically report improved athletic performance associated with chiropractic care.11
Limitations
The characteristics of the sample limit the breadth of perspectives represented in this study. Participants were relatively homogeneous in age and race, with all participants reporting between 10 and 47 years of running experience; more novice runners may describe different experiences and expectations for IPC. Participants also self-selected for this study, which may have resulted in greater participation among individuals with particularly positive or negative experiences. All participants were recruited through organized running groups in the Northeastern United States; runners who are not affiliated with organized groups or who live in other geographic regions may describe different experiences. These sample characteristics and the potential for self-selection bias limit the transferability of the findings.
Despite efforts to minimize investigator bias, such as second coding and reflexive journaling, researcher bias may still have impacted the importance ascribed to codes, patterns, and themes. It should be noted that we did not expect that some participants would share the perspective that IPC may not be expected or needed.
Future Research
Future research should include additional recreational athlete cohorts to determine whether recreational athletes who pursue other sports and activities are not affiliated with formal groups, represent other age groups and races, or have less running experience share similar experiences, expectations, and perceptions with those in this study. While the scope of this study precludes interpretations of the relationship between RRs and IPC, it should be noted that confounding variables, such as education level or economic status, may also influence the results.
In addition to exploring IPC in chiropractic care across different cohorts, it would also be useful to interview chiropractors and other HCPs, such as physical therapists, orthopedists, and orthopedic surgeons, to elicit their experiences with and perspectives on IPC. Similarly, comparing the IPC experiences of RRs who receive care from certified sports chiropractors with those who receive care from general chiropractors may provide further insight.
The chiropractor’s focus and acumen may also be relevant to the patient experience with IPC. This study did not distinguish the experiences of RRs who received care from general chiropractors from those who were treated by certified sports chiropractors. In a descriptive study that surveyed 154 certified sports chiropractors, 92% reported collaborating with other HCPs, and 58% frequently co-managed with physical therapists, massage therapists, and orthopedic surgeons.41 It may be useful to compare RRs’ experiences and expectations depending on whether treatment was provided by a generalist versus a certified sports chiropractor.
Furthermore, moving beyond a focus on chiropractic care to include other professional disciplines may broaden the impact of future research. It may be of interest to conduct an applied research study of IPC between chiropractors and co-located HCPs, which may provide further insight into the expectations, benefits, and application of IPC in practice.
CONCLUSION
This study contributes to understanding how RRs in chiropractic care may expect and experience IPC and how they perceive its value. Unlike the professional athletes studied in the earlier-mentioned research studies, RRs in this qualitative descriptive investigation generally did not experience or expect to experience IPC in their chiropractic treatment. However, some participants who experienced IPC surrounding serious injuries that required surgery described the perceived benefits that IPC provided. All participants noted that IPC is a valued practice and may be particularly useful for many RRs whose care requires more coordination, advocacy, and navigation.
The data from this study show that RRs exhibit a range of expectations and experiences with IPC in chiropractic care, suggesting that chiropractors explore individual patients’ needs and expectations for IPC. The results of this study may inform future research that explores the relationships between IPC and RRs’ outcomes, as well as HCP perspectives on IPC’s role and impact in treatment, with the goals of improving treatment outcomes, patient confidence, and patient satisfaction.
Acknowledgements
The author gratefully acknowledges Kirby Wycoff, PsyD, EdM, MPH, NCSP and Jacelyn Biondo, Ph.D., MPH, MA, BC-DMT, LPC for their guidance and oversight during the conduct of the study; Stephanie Parker, DHSc and Brian Schwartz, DHSc for their contributions as second-coders; Shawn Gonzalez, Ph.D. for mentoring scholarly writing; and Ethan Wasserman, MS for his project management assistance.