INTRODUCTION
D. D. Palmer, the founder of chiropractic, embedded vitalistic concepts such as life force and intelligent life into the profession’s ontological foundations.1–4 However, this philosophy has been controversial within the profession. Some chiropractors have identified Palmer’s key concept of innate intelligence as vitalistic,5–7 and as a feature distinguishing chiropractic from mechanistic allopathic medicine.8,9 Offering a philosophically defensible position4 of a coherent relationship with the natural world,7,10 and manifest in practice3,11 vitalism has been linked to healthy lifestyles, optimal health, and wellness.12–15 Indeed, the expression of innate intelligence as an important and positive characteristic of chiropractic16–18 was generalized to a broader section of the profession in the results of a 1997 nation-wide consensus process which involved Australian chiropractors.13 Participants placed recognition of innate intelligence as the first core value of chiropractic and the upholding of this value as a core purpose of the Chiropractors’ Association of Australia (CAA).
Nonetheless, by 2018 the CAA had changed its name to the Australian Chiropractors’ Association (ACA) and changed its policy toward its members’ vitalistic core value. Expression of this philosophy was relegated from an Association priority to a belief of individual members appropriately expressed only in private practice. In referring to “non-scientific ‘Vitalistic dogma’”,19 the new policy reflected the broader anti-vitalism literature, in which vitalism has been described as a divisive, magical, aberrant, unorthodox, pseudo-religious theological dogma.20–25 In fact, one author posed that, as some chiropractic techniques involve x-ray imaging, x-ray machines were sacred artefacts and radiographs were religious symbols comparable to the Christian crucifix.26
Furthermore, vitalistic views were considered by some as errors of logic neither testable27 nor defendable19 by scientific methods and therefore not evidence-based.22 As such, vitalism excluded the profession from orthodoxy, science, and the health system.22,28–30 It was also claimed that there was no place for vitalism as an explanatory framework in modern chiropractic education or practice, other than as historical interest, and it should be replaced with science.19,30,31 Moreover, the deviant minority of the profession who adhered to this dogma should be reported to the authorities21,32 via an avenue established for such reporting.30
However, both sides of this debate have been mainly in the form of commentaries. These are often not subject to the rigor of peer preview and have been largely based on opinion, which can be subject to bias.33,34 Until recently, there has been little empirical evidence about what chiropractors actually mean when they speak about vitalism, and the value they think it might offer.
One qualitative study found that, to a small group of chiropractic academics in New Zealand, vitalism was a conception of the body as a self-healing, self-organising, and self-regulating organism, and offered value as a guide in the teaching, learning, and practice of chiropractic.35 A mixed-methods 3-phase sequential series of studies then explored what meaning chiropractors attribute to vitalism and what value thinking and practices based on it might offer in addressing current global prevalence of non-communicable lifestyle-related conditions (NCLRCs). The first phase of this series was qualitative and involved interviews of 18 purposefully selected key informant chiropractors from 8 countries.36 Interview items were derived mainly from review of relevant literature. To a majority of interviewees, vitalism meant innate intelligence, a guide to a good life, and a core essence of the identity of chiropractic To a minority, vitalism meant a neo-vitalism involving recognition of the self-organizing, self-maintaining, self-healing abilities of living things; or a practice style which involved over-servicing and damaged the profession’s reputation; or an historic school of thought which had never been proven scientifically and threatened the profession’s survival. Most interviewees felt that vitalism offered great value in addressing prevalence of NCLRCs, as vitalistic chiropractic could empower individuals to take control of their lives and to live healthy lifestyles.
The second phase of this series of studies was quantitative and sought to test the generalizability of the first phase interview findings to a different population composed of a much broader section of the profession.15 This involved development of a Qualtrics online survey with the survey items developed from the relevant literature (noted above) and the interview findings.36,37 The survey consisted of up to 62 closed-ended and up to 22 open-ended items and was pilot tested (see Appendix A). An email invitation to participate in the survey was issued to chiropractor members of the Chiropractors’ Association of Australia and of the New Zealand Chiropractors’ Association 4 times in the month beginning May 8, 2018.
The responses to the second phase survey’s closed-ended questions can be summarized as follows3,15: To the majority of respondents, vitalism meant a traditional form of vitalism best expressed as universal and innate intelligence; a legitimate school of thought; a positive for the profession; and an essential part of the identity of chiropractic. The majority also disagreed that vitalism has no place in contemporary or evidence-based chiropractic practice. A majority of 62.0% agreed and 25.9% disagreed that chiropractic thinking and practices based on vitalism might offer value in addressing current global prevalence of NCLRCs. Within the limits of the sample, these results supported cautious generalization of the findings of the first phase interviews to a broader and different section of the profession. This present article now extends further the testing of the generalizability of the first phase interview findings36 by reporting on the third phase of the series of studies. This third phase involved the qualitative responses to the open-ended questions posed in the survey.
METHODS
Data Preparation
Cleaning of the data to remove responses which did not answer 3 or more survey items resulted in the elimination of 104 responses, leaving 307 responses for analysis. This exceeded the calculated required sample size of 226.15 Responses to each open-ended item were copied into a separate Microsoft Word document for each question to facilitate analysis.
Data Analysis
The 1,041 written responses to the open-ended items were analysed using the 6-step process of thematic analysis described by Braun and Clarke.38 In this process, coding involved key words and concepts being identified using the method described by Neuman39 (see Appendix B). The thematic analysis of these responses and reporting of it were conducted from a research stance of descriptive phenomenology.40,41 This was appropriate because the open-ended survey items were posed in terms of the respondents’ lived experiences of meanings, expressions, and values of vitalism in chiropractic thinking and practice.
Multiple procedures were used in seeking high standards of truthfulness, trustworthiness, credibility and authenticity for the thematic analysis, reporting, and discussing of data in this present study.42 The researchers repeatedly reminded themselves of the requirement for phenomenological bracketing, that is, to attempt to set aside personal beliefs about the phenomena under consideration.43,44 Other procedures used included deep engagement with the data, researcher reflexivity, disconfirming evidence, triangulation, and keeping an audit trail.38,42–46 Finally, thick, rich description was used in presentation of the findings.42
RESULTS
The four themes which were identified in the data can be seen in Table 1.
The first three of these themes are now explicated with illustrative quotes from survey responses included in the description of each theme. Survey responses were anonymous so it was not possible to identify who contributed each quote. Also identified from the survey responses was a fourth theme of 2 different practice models, vitalistic and non-vitalistic. Due to the large amount of relevant data provided by respondents and space limitations, this theme will be addressed in a future article.
Theme 1. Vitalism means innate intelligence
Many respondents referred to both vitalism and “innate intelligence”. This latter term is a traditional chiropractic term which has been used to refer to the concept of an inborn intelligence in humans which guides and regulates body function, outside of conscious awareness.1 Innate intelligence was regarded as vitalistic as it was considered to operate through a vitalistic life force and was what many respondents meant when they wrote of vitalism:
For chiropractors … there is a vitalistic component that in past days was described as being “innate intelligence”. The life force that exists in life is part of that.
Many pro-vitalism respondents expressed an attitude of reverence and trust towards living organisms and their intelligent life force, believing that, as long as it was not interfered with, this intelligence acted to maintain the body in optimal condition and function, producing health and healing:
The trust in “innate” adds an unlimited and unmeasurable layer to the patient’s general optimism, ability to heal and function to the best of its ability.
I trust the innate intelligence in the body to know how to heal someone rather than thinking that I am responsible for the healing.
These respondents regarded the existence and role of this force as a timeless foundational part of not only the philosophical framework of chiropractic but of all parts of the profession’s activities:
I recognise and accept “innate intelligence” as a fundamental principle of chiropractic in the past, present and future.
[Vitalism] represents the golden thread which runs through the fabric of all chiropractic.
In contrast, a small minority of respondents strongly held opposite views. Their comments included:
The non-vitalist chiropractor has no reliance on Innate Intelligence.
Do they truly trust innate intelligence?
While neo-vitalism had been proposed as a contemporary version of vitalism, there was little awareness of it and its meaning amongst respondents. One summed up the responses of many by stating "I am not familiar with neo-vitalism." Most respondents who did comment on neo-vitalism considered it to be the same as or similar to vitalism: "I see neo-vitalism and vitalism as the same school of thought." One respondent’s comment "Deck chairs on the Titanic" suggested that vitalism was a lost cause and that changing its name would make no difference*.* However, without specifically using the term “neo-vitalism”, several respondents used terms which have been associated with it, such as “self-regulating,” “self-healing,” and “organising”:
Our body has the capability that has been designed/or developed over the eons to be a self-regulating, self-healing organism …
Helping patients be inspired by the fact that their body is self-healing and self-organising.
Theme 2. Different worldviews
Pro- and anti-vitalism respondents differed substantially in how they perceived, described, and presented their own views and practices, and those of the other group. The majority pro-vitalism group generally addressed their own thinking and practices in confident, optimistic, and matter-of-fact tones. Some criticised in relatively mild terms what they considered to be the general practice model of their anti-vitalism colleagues, describing it as the mechanistic, reductionist treatment of musculoskeletal dysfunction to eliminate symptoms in those structures:
[Vitalistic] practice is driven by a wholistic philosophy based on self-healing to improve overall health and wellness, not just treating symptoms of musculoskeletal problems.
I’ve found over the years, a clinic with this [vitalistic] philosophy has a happier, more positive energy than mechanistic symptom-based clinics.
I don’t judge non-vitalistic practices. I’m really happy that we have people in both camps. Humans aren’t all the same and aren’t wanting all the same things.
In contrast, some anti-vitalists responded with agitation, frustration, and anger. They strongly criticised vitalism as an outdated, metaphysical, religious, unmeasurable, pseudoscientific, and unscientific dogma:
Are you kidding? I am not in a profession to sell voodoo snake oils.
It’s no different to a religion.
Australian chiropractors have caught a “tent revivalist” contagi[on] from a small minority of similarly narrow-minded maverick US chiropractors who have wandered the health care prairies in the US for over a century, unwilling to abandon outmoded philosophies that suited an ill-informed time gone by.
Vitalism is a scourge on the profession.
Many anti-vitalists used science as a basis to negatively judge vitalism:
Until you can use the scientific method to test the philosophical concept of vitalism, then it has no place in healthcare.
Vitalism is unsubstantiated. It is an historic concept that is still not supported by any credible research.
Vitalism was superseded as a legitimate component of biological sciences over 100 years ago. That is a simple fact.
While pro-vitalists made little comment on the characters, motivations, ethics, or practices of the anti-vitalists, many anti-vitalists harshly criticised the vitalists, describing them in terms such as “credulous,” “under-educated,” “narrow-minded,” “arrogant,” “greedy,” “unethical,” “pseudoscientific,” and “quacks.” Indeed, according to one respondent:
All vitalistic chiro[s] are a shame and should get wiped out from the profession.
Some anti-vitalists asserted that some vitalists used their own personal faith, rather than science, as the basis for what the vitalists believed to be an ultimate form of health care. A common criticism from anti-vitalists was that vitalists used vitalism as propaganda in practice management strategies to over-service:
[I]ncreased fanaticism for vitalism loosely correlates with increased unethical behaviours including, but not limited to, over-servicing.
Such over-servicing was described as taking the form of lengthy programs of care based on philosophical rather than scientific considerations. Such care was described as aimed at eliminating vertebral subluxations, which some anti-vitalists said were unproven or non-existent. For many anti-vitalists, this approach was to increase practice income:
The over-servicing mainly occurs due to the schedule of care being made based on vitalistic and philosophical (dogmatic) principles rather than evidence-based, patient-centred or even basic science principles.
[Vitalistic chiropractors] need to use scare tactics to get people in the door. They need to treat people with a theoretical condition that is not proven (i.e. subluxation). There is no consensus on how to find or treat a theoretical condition.
This unethical and unscientific approach was driven by the profit motive.
Many anti-vitalists argued strongly that vitalism in chiropractic denigrated the reputation of the profession and hindered its acceptance into mainstream scientific multidisciplinary health care. Until vitalism could be tested by the scientific method, there was no place for it:
Vitalism is an unsupported notion, no more than an article of faith and has no place in the provision of modern health care.
Some anti-vitalism respondents strongly felt that vitalism in chiropractic and its potential benefits should not even be discussed.
I feel ashamed and embarrassed of the profession when such retarded ideas are discussed as if they have anything to do with it.
[T]here is NO PLACE for the discussion of vitalism in mainstream health care. There is NO PLACE for the discussion that vitalistic ways could add value to the services chiropractors offer by focusing on the creation of health, rather than fighting disease.
This is a ridiculous conversation to be having in the 21st century. Why not have a discussion about the evidence for fairies or dragons?
Congruent with the view that vitalism should not be discussed, some respondents offered strategies to manage the risk they believed vitalism posed to the future of the profession:
A more useful discussion would be to try to find out why people believe in things for which there is no evidence, and how to rid the profession of those practitioners, or rehabilitate them.
These differences concerning vitalism were also reflected in the different ways pro- and anti-vitalism respondents described their practices.
Theme 3. Focus on vitalism and practice
Some respondents believed that vitalistic thinking should be emphasised in all aspects of chiropractic, including education, practice, and research. They regarded vitalism as a guiding concept for these activities:
It represents the golden thread which runs through the fabric of all chiropractic.
Vitalistic thinking should drive the questions being asked in all education, practice and research.
Many respondents made suggestions as to how vitalism could be expressed in practice. These included via wholistic thinking based on acceptance of the role of innate intelligence in life and the interference of subluxation to that; patient education emphasising the body’s self-healing ability, healthy body function, and lifestyles; and wellbeing and the maximum expression of life potential, rather than just addressing symptoms.
Similarly, in education, many respondents believed that the medical and mechanistic science approach should be reduced and there should be greater appreciation, study, discussion, and reinforcement of the fundamental premises of chiropractic, including vitalism. These areas should be taught by persons with adequate knowledge of vitalistic viewpoints.
Respondents were less sure about the expression of vitalism in science. While one stated that vitalism cannot be researched via science, many argued that research questions influenced by vitalism would involve investigations of the effects of subluxation and adjustment, particularly on body function and quality of life. Approaches involving exploration of complementary relationships between philosophy, science, and practice were also suggested:
Chiropractic is the dynamic blend of vitalistic principles and mechanistic practices. One cannot exist without the other so it is essential that we integrate both of these throughout all aspects of chiropractic.
Weave the philosophy of chiropractic into the science and art I practice.
Not all respondents saw vitalism as an important guide. Congruent with the overall view of anti-vitalists that there was no place for vitalism in the profession in general, these respondents believed that there was no place for it in education or research. This was because they perceived vitalism as a non-scientific perspective which could not be part of a science-based profession:
[Vitalism’s] inclusion into education and practice produces generations of individuals who are well meaning, credulous and easy victims for frauds. It lowers, never raises, standards and is philosophically professionally unethical (since it is an article of faith … it is within the realm of religious practice). It basically encourages people to “faith heal” and ignore their duty as providers of objective advice.
No respondents suggested research into the philosophical school of thought of vitalism itself.
DISCUSSION
This present research extends the testing of the generalizability to a broader sample of research exploring the meaning and value of vitalism in chiropractic.3,14,15,36 From the responses to the survey open-ended questions the 4 themes noted in Table 1 were identified as key findings. From the first theme it was clear that, to a majority of survey respondents, vitalism first meant the chiropractic concept of innate intelligence and that it offered great value to the profession and those it serves. Such equating of Palmer’s concept of innate intelligence to vitalism1 is common to pro- and anti-vitalism authors in the opinion-based4,7,10,21,23,29 and evidence-based15,36 literature, and does not support anecdotal evidence that chiropractors cannot define the term vitalism.23
However, beyond this fundamental agreement about meaning, divisions over other meanings and value of vitalism in the findings reflected similar divisions in the literature, based on different worldviews. To a majority of respondents, vitalism had positive meanings. They confidently and optimistically expressed reverence, respect, and trust towards innate intelligence. Without animosity, the right of others to hold non-vitalist viewpoints was acknowledged, as was that practices based on such viewpoints could legitimately serve patients seeking that kind of care. As did Palmer,1 these vitalist respondents seemed to accept and combine vitalist, materialist, and scientific worldviews.36 Some of the public may find these positive and wholistic attitudes attractive22 and this may contribute toward chiropractors practicing in this traditional vitalist chiropractic explanatory framework,30 reporting seeing larger numbers of patients,15 and earning higher incomes47 than other chiropractors. Reflecting the pro-vitalism literature, none of these respondents likened vitalism to religion. Furthermore, their view of vitalism as a core part of the profession’s philosophy and practice supported relevant literature.6,15,18,36
In contrast, for most anti-vitalism respondents, vitalism held strongly negative meanings. These were expressed in frustration, agitation, anger, resentment, and hostility toward vitalistic practitioners, their beliefs, and their work. Indeed, reflecting anti-vitalism literature,21,28,30 some respondents proposed that vitalism should not be discussed at all and that vitalist colleagues be rehabilitated or eliminated from the profession. Vitalistic practice was also said to involve unethical behaviours.29,36
These opposing findings may be explained by polarization and fanaticism. Polarization involves separation between persons of competing political or ideological positions. Affective (emotional) polarization is an intense level of polarization in which those who strongly hold certain views develop contempt and hatred for other views and those who hold them,48 as can be seen in these deeply negative attitudes towards vitalism and vitalists. Interestingly, while vitalism in chiropractic has been described by some authors as divisive,21,23,27,29,49 it is these same anti-vitalism authors and survey respondents who promote divisiveness. In contrast, vitalist authors and respondents overall presented live-and-let-live attitudes toward non-vitalists.
Fanaticism has been described as dedication to a sacred value which defines the identity of the fanatic and involves hostility towards other viewpoints and holders of them, when these others are considered to threaten the sacred value.50,51 A sacred value is held to be infinite, absolute, unquestionable, and immune from rational critique. Fanatics fear dissent, which can cause them anxiety by threatening their sacred value, the certainty it offers, and their personal identity and self-worth attached to it via psychic dependence. Such anxiety makes group insider identity based on shared commitment to the sacred value important as an antidote to the fanatic’s fragile identity, which requires external affirmation. Any opposing outside group is blamed for perceived problems, reacted against, and, if possible, suppressed.
One survey respondent referred to fanaticism on the part of vitalists. However, while many survey respondents did hold innate intelligence as a revered and respected value and a part of an infinite intelligence, none claimed it to be unquestionable or immune from critique. Their acceptance of dissent from their vitalistic values, lack of hostility towards colleagues holding other views, and confident attitudes do not suggest that the vitalists have anxiety or fragile identities. Therefore, according to the above understandings of fanaticism,50,51 they could not be accurately described as fanatics holding vitalism as innate intelligence as a sacred value.
In contrast, some survey respondents displayed marked hostility towards vitalism and vitalistic colleagues, terms, and practices, to the point that these should be suppressed or eliminated. This hostility appeared related to belief that vitalism was unsupported and unproven by putative standards of science and was therefore invalid and unacceptable. Science appeared to be these respondents’ absolute criteria for judgement of all legitimacy in chiropractic and a source of external affirmation in the form of acceptance into the putative expectations of patients, science, and mainstream health care. It therefore appears that these anti-vitalists, and others expressing similar views in the literature,19,21,22,27–31 held science as an absolute sacred value and held hostility to another viewpoint (vitalism), thereby meeting the criteria to be described as fanatics.50,51 See Table 2.
Based on Tietjen50 and Katsafanas51
These anti-vitalism attitudes may also be better understood via scientism and category mistake. Adherents to scientism hold that all beliefs and decisions should be based in science.52,53 Only knowledge derived via science is legitimate knowledge, so any questions which cannot be answered by scientific methods, including those about philosophy and religion, have no meaning.54 However, these claims of scientism themselves cannot be established by scientific methods, so scientism is invalid by its own criteria.55 Yet many anti-vitalism respondents and authors used scientism to reject vitalism.19,22,23,27–29 In doing so, they commit an error of logic known as category mistake.56,57 In this, things of one kind (e.g. the philosophical concepts of vitalism) are invalidly represented as if they were of another different kind (e.g. material objects of scientific research). In essence, apples are judged by the criteria of oranges. In addition, some anti-vitalism respondents and authors20,29 saw vitalism as religion, which appears as another category mistake.
The marked differences in opinions about vitalism might further be understood by the results of a content analysis survey on the teaching of philosophy in chiropractic.58 While every known chiropractic educational institution was invited to participate, only 12 institutions responded, all American. Of these, 10 taught nothing about classical philosophy itself. The other 2 taught less than 10 hours, including about the nature of philosophy, metaphysics, epistemology, logic, and their relations to science. Regarding traditional chiropractic philosophy, 6 institutions taught 10 hours or less, including one which taught no hours. Three taught more than 30 hours. These figures suggest 2 distinct approaches to the teaching of philosophy in chiropractic. One holds it to be important, the other much less. Overall, there was great variety in the content and amount of chiropractic philosophy taught, with most students receiving no training in philosophy itself. How much these American findings might apply to Australia59–61 and New Zealand is not clear. However, the fanaticism, scientism, and category mistake noted in this present study may be due to lack of education in and understanding of the true natures and roles of philosophy and science.
In this present study, many respondents felt that vitalism should be expressed in all aspects of chiropractic and made some suggestions as to how. None suggested that vitalism could be explored as something greater than as it is understood in chiropractic, or as it may form an important part of Western history and culture. Other respondents rejected that vitalism should have any place at all. Confirming previous literature, most respondents showed little awareness of neo-vitalism as such, or considered it to be the same as vitalism.15,35
Limitations
Despite the above-mentioned attempts to seek high standards in this present study, its reliability may be limited in several ways. Firstly, the researchers’ values, educations, and work experiences may have influenced their contributions. The first author has qualifications and experience in science, chiropractic, and philosophy and the second author in chiropractic, osteopathy, and tertiary education. Secondly, the researchers’ abilities to bracket may have been limited.43 Thirdly, the study sample was limited and the findings should not be taken as applying to all chiropractors in Australia and New Zealand. The sample was, however, the largest the researchers could access. Fourthly, while the survey was carefully constructed, pilot tested, and modified accordingly, different survey items may have produced different responses and findings.
CONCLUSION
This present study continued the testing of the generalizability of previous research findings to a broader sample of the profession.3,15,36 Responses to the survey open-ended questions largely confirmed those previous findings, suggesting that they might be cautiously generalised across the profession. To most respondents, vitalism meant innate intelligence, which they considered to be a positive and valuable part of the profession’s identity which should be emphasised in all aspects of chiropractic. To a minority, vitalism was a negative which should be abandoned. These different perspectives were based on different worldviews.
This study also continued the replacement of opinion-based literature on vitalism in chiropractic with data- and evidence-based material. This process will proceed with reporting of the vitalistic and non-vitalistic practice models mentioned in Theme 4. Further research could explore why the vitalistic practice model may offer value to many patients; why attempts have been made to suppress it; the affective polarisation, fanaticism, and scientism identified; and whether better quantity and quality of education in philosophy might lead to a better-informed and less divisive debate within the profession over vitalism, and contribute to wider use of chiropractic.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
Elizabeth Emmanuel, B.Nurs., M.Nurs. Ph.D., for assistance in conception, design and analysis.
CONTRIBUTION LIST
DR: Contributed to conception, design, data acquisition, analysis, drafting, and review.
SG: Contributed to conception, design, analysis, review, and editing.
ETHICAL STATEMENT
The Southern Cross University Human Research Ethics Committee provided ethics approval (Number ECN-16-161) for the study. Voluntary participation in the study survey signified informed consent.
FUNDING STATEMENT
This research received no specific grant from any funding agency in the public, commercial, or not-for-profit sectors.
DECLARATION OF CONFLICTING INTERESTS
The Authors declare that there are no conflicts of interest.